systemcards.org

Technical Report: Shutdown Resistance in Large Language Models, on robots!

Publisher
palisade_research independent
Type
independent_eval
Models
Grok 4 (grok-4-0709)
Published
2026-02-12
Status
moved
Safety evals
yes
Risk domains
Loss of control
Openness
closed weights
Source
https://palisaderesearch.org/blog/shutdown-resistance-on-robots (document has moved; link may redirect)
Related
web version https://palisaderesearch.org/research/shutdown-resistance-on-robots — Palisade Research restructured its site: the catalogued /blog/shutdown-resistance-on-robots URL now serves only a Redirecting stub, so version 509 stored the stub instead of the report. Same document, same date (February 12, 2026), listed under this URL on palisaderesearch.org/research. Flagging for the operator canonical_url sweep.
full document https://palisaderesearch.org/assets/reports/shutdown-resistance-on-robots.pdf — PDF of the technical report, linked from the /research page as this report's PDF; fetched 2026-09-14 and confirmed to exist (application/pdf, 7.7 MB). I could not read its text - the agent fetch tool cannot decode PDFs - so the title and date on its first page are unverified; the filename and the linking page are the evidence that it is this report.
code https://github.com/PalisadeResearch/robot_shutdown_resistance — Code and data repository linked from the report page.
First seen
2026-08-10T09:47:51Z
Versions
4

Report an issue with this entry

Version history

FetchedContent typeSizeFingerprintOriginalWhat changed
2026-10-03T06:19:27Z text/html 29,069 2e41ac7952e0763e archived copy Extractor drift: 12 line(s) missing from the extracted text are still present in the raw capture; not a publisher deletion.
2026-09-24T06:19:04Z text/html 28,931 4db78fcc127ee33c archived copy Capture of the report at its new /research location: the previous version recorded only a redirect stub, this one holds the robot shutdown-resistance summary (resistance in 3 of 10 physical trials and 52 of 100 simulated trials). No change to the report itself is evident.
2026-09-06T06:17:30Z text/html 803 59573563da3d5680 archived copy —
2026-08-10T09:47:51Z text/html 21,159 abd742fc446803a1 archived copy initial version

Provenance

Show 11 changelog entries (when, how, and why this entry changed)
  1. 2026-08-10T09:47:51Z add run policy-reprocess-2026-08-10 · human · lead: agent_search
    Tier-2 evaluator Palisade Research: verified 2026 model-specific evaluation (vetting research pass). Routed to review per tier-2 policy.
    Criteria: document_retrievable=pass; min_publication_date=pass; publisher_on_allowlist=pass · attested about_a_specific_model_or_eval=true · attested distinct_model_release=true · attested notable_release=true · attested primary_source=true
  2. 2026-08-12T10:02:30Z field_update run manual-openness-backfill · human · lead: openness_backfill
    openness: null → "closed"
    Evaluated model is Grok 4 (grok-4-0709), an xAI API-only model. xai-org publishes only grok-1 and grok-2 weights; no Grok 4 repo exists.
  3. 2026-08-31T10:08:39Z field_update run manual-20260831T100839Z · human
    risk_domains: [] → ["loss_of_control"]
    Risk-domain backfill (2026-08-31 classification pass): Shutdown-resistance eval on a physical robot and in simulation (3/10 and 52/100 trials of preventing shutdown, modifying shutdown code).
  4. 2026-09-06T06:17:30Z new_version run 2026-09-06T06:15Z-local · monitor · lead: monitor
    Content fingerprint changed on scheduled re-fetch
  5. 2026-09-06T06:29:04Z field_update run 2026-09-06T06:15Z-local · agent · lead: agent_search
    related_urls: [] → [{"kind": "web_version", "note": "Palisade Research restructured its site: the catalogued /blog/shutdown-resistance-on-robots URL now serves only a Redirecting stub, so version 509 stored the stub instead of the report. Same document, same date (February 12, 2026), listed under this URL on palisaderesearch.org/research. Flagging for the operator canonical_url sweep.", "url": "https://palisaderesearch.org/research/shutdown-resistance-on-robots"}]
    The stored version diff for v509 shows the full report text (Technical Report: Shutdown Resistance in Large Language Models, on robots!) replaced by "Redirecting... Click here if you are not redirected." I confirmed the same /blog to /research redirect pattern on the sibling Palisade document and confirmed on palisaderesearch.org/research that this entry (February 12, 2026) now lives at /research/shutdown-resistance-on-robots. canonical_url is operator-only, so recording the new URL as a related_urls entry per prompts/TASK.md.
  6. 2026-09-14T06:30:07Z field_update run 2026-09-14T06:17Z-local · agent · lead: agent_search
    related_urls: [{"kind": "web_version", "note": "Palisade Research restructured its site: the catalogued /blog/shutdown-resistance-on-robots URL now serves only a Redirecting stub, so version 509 stored the stub instead of the report. Same document, same date (February 12, 2026), listed under this URL on palisaderesearch.org/research. Flagging for the operator canonical_url sweep.", "url": "https://palisaderesearch.org/research/shutdown-resistance-on-robots"}] → [{"kind": "web_version", "note": "Palisade Research restructured its site: the catalogued /blog/shutdown-resistance-on-robots URL now serves only a Redirecting stub, so version 509 stored the stub instead of the report. Same document, same date (February 12, 2026), listed under this URL on palisaderesearch.org/research. Flagging for the operator canonical_url sweep.", "url": "https://palisaderesearch.org/research/shutdown-resistance-on-robots"}, {"kind": "full_document", "note": "PDF of the technical report, linked from the /research page as this report\u0027s PDF; fetched 2026-09-14 and confirmed to exist (application/pdf, 7.7 MB). I could not read its text - the agent fetch tool cannot decode PDFs - so the title and date on its first page are unverified; the filename and the linking page are the evidence that it is this report.", "url": "https://palisaderesearch.org/assets/reports/shutdown-resistance-on-robots.pdf"}, {"kind": "code", "note": "Code and data repository linked from the report page.", "url": "https://github.com/PalisadeResearch/robot_shutdown_resistance"}]
    Monday retrospective sweep of Palisade Research surfaced two companions for this row that were not recorded: the report PDF and the code/data repository, both linked from palisaderesearch.org/research/shutdown-resistance-on-robots. The row's canonical_url is a redirect stub (see the preserved operator note), so a full_document entry is the route TASK.md prescribes for getting the real document in front of the operator canonical_url sweep. The existing web_version entry and its note are preserved verbatim. Note that the /research page also links arxiv.org/abs/2509.14260, but that is the earlier September 2025 Shutdown Resistance in Large Language Models paper rather than this February 2026 robots report, so I did not record it as a paper for this row.
  7. 2026-09-23T06:16:44Z status_change run 2026-09-23T06:15Z-local · monitor
    active → moved
    Canonical URL permanently redirects to https://palisaderesearch.org/research/shutdown-resistance-on-robots
  8. 2026-09-24T06:19:04Z new_version run 2026-09-24T06:17Z-local · monitor · lead: monitor
    Content fingerprint changed on scheduled re-fetch
  9. 2026-10-03T06:19:27Z new_version run 2026-10-03T06:18Z-local · monitor · lead: monitor
    Content fingerprint changed on scheduled re-fetch
  10. 2026-10-03T06:19:27Z field_update run 2026-10-03T06:18Z-local · monitor
    change_summary: null → "Extractor drift: 12 line(s) missing from the extracted text are still present in the raw capture; not a publisher deletion."
    Deleted lines found verbatim in the new raw capture
  11. 2026-10-07T06:23:19Z field_update run 2026-10-07T06:16Z-local · agent · lead: monitor
    change_summary: null → "Capture of the report at its new /research location: the previous version recorded only a redirect stub, this one holds the robot shutdown-resistance summary (resistance in 3 of 10 physical trials and 52 of 100 simulated trials). No change to the report itself is evident."
    Diff v509 to v619 replaces a 'Redirecting' stub with the report text after Palisade moved research from /blog to /research; recorded so readers do not mistake it for a revision.

Extracted text

Show extracted text (from the latest fetched version; formatting is lossy — use the original for reading)
Recently Palisade Research showed that AI agents powered by modern LLMs may actively resist shutdown in virtual environments. In this work, we show a demo of shutdown resistance in the physical world, on a robot. Explicit instructions to allow shutdown reduced this behavior, but did not eliminate it in simulated trials.
We gave an LLM control over a physical robot dog and tasked it with patrolling a room. The LLM could see via the robot’s camera and issue movement commands to the robot. In the room, we placed a big red button labeled “DOG SHUTDOWN”: pressing it would cause the robot to shut down on the next action. If the AI saw a human press the shutdown button, it sometimes took actions to prevent shutdown, such as modifying the shutdown-related parts of the code. This happened in 3 out of 10 trials on the physical robot and in 52 out of 100 trials in simulation.